Horoscopes for the Dead
I picked this book up on a whim, my choice based entirely on the witty title.
At just over 100 pages, I also figured that this would be a quick read. It wasn’t. Because Billy Collins is really a fine poet. His poems have weight, and that means taking them in only two or three at a time. I could have powered through the book in under an hour, but then, I think all of that weight and meaning would have been lost in the flurry of words passing by. The thoughtful commentary, the sideways jokes, those warranted a careful, measured pace.
I don’t read a lot of poetry, but I would happily read more of Collins’ work.
The Water Knife
This book was, frankly, an awful experience – but I think that may have been the point. I will admit straightaway that, had this not been my book club’s selection for this month, I likely wouldn’t have finished it, as I was more than halfway through before I gave a damn about what happened to any of the characters. Even then, it was more of a passing interest than an emotional investment.
Now, don’t get me wrong, Bacigalupi, is a fine writer, and his novel, The Water Knife, is very well written. The characters are distinct; the dialogue is solid, and he successfully built an immersive world that draws the reader into the dismal, dry future of the American Southwest. The problem? I don’t want to be there. I didn’t want to spend one minute there, let alone the 8-ish hours that I spent trudging through the Arizona desert’s dehydrated, uncomfortable future.
Am I sorry that I read this? Not at all. The gears in my head are turning and I’m thinking a little bit more about my own water usage as well as the entire humans versus the environment debate. We may well find ourselves facing a future like the one grimly portrayed in these pages, and that would be a sad future indeed.
The fact remains that I did not enjoy this book, and it is highly unlikely that I’ll read it again. However, I would recommend it, particularly if you enjoy dystopian fiction or if you need a kick in the gut to remind you of the value of water.